charcoal toothpaste

Comparing Whitening Effects: Purple vs. Charcoal Toothpaste

Comparing Whitening Effects: Purple vs. Charcoal Toothpaste

Tooth whitening is a huge market worldwide, worth billions. Many people want a brighter smile. They try different products, like purple and charcoal toothpaste, hoping to whiten their teeth. But are these products good at what they claim? Are they safe to use every day? In this piece, we'll look at how well purple and charcoal toothpaste whiten teeth. We'll see their good and bad points. By the end, you'll know which one is best for a sparkling smile.

Key Takeaways:

  • Charcoal toothpaste is made from activated charcoal and may help remove surface stains, but it is highly abrasive and lacks fluoride.
  • Purple toothpaste contains an illusionary ingredient that temporarily shifts tooth color, but it does not result in actual whitening.
  • Consider other teeth whitening options, such as ADA-approved whitening toothpastes or professional treatments, for more effective and long-lasting results.
  • Consult with a dentist to determine the best teeth whitening option for your specific needs and to address any concerns about safety.
  • Always prioritize oral health by practicing good oral hygiene and visiting your dentist regularly.

Understanding Charcoal Toothpaste

Charcoal toothpaste comes from activated charcoal. This is a fine-grain powder made from natural things like wood and coconut shells. It says it can remove stains from teeth. But it's very rough and shouldn't be used every day. This toothpaste doesn't have fluoride, which is needed to keep teeth from getting cavities.

It might help with stains at first. But we're not sure about it in the long run. Some worry it could hurt the enamel on teeth and make them sensitive. We still need more studies to know if it's really safe and good to use.

Exploring Purple Toothpaste for Whitening

Purple color-correcting toothpaste uses an active ingredient called blue covarine to make teeth look whiter. It puts a thin, see-through layer on the tooth's surface. This layer tricks the eye, changing yellow tones into a blue hue. This makes the teeth look whiter than they are.

The change in color from purple toothpaste is not permanent. It doesn’t actually whiten the teeth. While it may work right away for some people, this might not last a long time. You would need to keep using purple toothpaste to keep up the white appearance.

Does purple toothpaste work? It makes teeth look whiter for a short while, but it doesn't really whiten them. You have to use it often to maintain the effect. More research is needed on its actual whitening power and safety.

"Purple toothpaste can make teeth look whiter by changing yellow to blue, but it doesn’t actually whiten the teeth."

Benefits and Limitations of Purple Toothpaste for Whitening

Here's what purple toothpaste can and cannot do for whiter teeth:

Benefits Limitations
- Creates an illusion of whiter teeth - Temporary color shift
- Easy to use - Requires continuous use for desired effect
- Non-abrasive - Does not result in actual tooth whitening

Pros and Cons of Charcoal Toothpaste

Charcoal toothpaste has upsides and downsides for teeth whitening. Knowing these can help you decide if it's right for you. This choice is important for your dental care.

Benefits of Charcoal Toothpaste

Charcoal toothpaste is known for removing light stains and freshening breath. It has activated charcoal, known for its cleaning properties. This helps take off plaque and dirt from your teeth.

Using charcoal toothpaste now and then can stop new stains. This is especially true after you've had a professional dental cleaning. It keeps your smile bright by tackling those easy-to-see stains.

Drawbacks of Charcoal Toothpaste

Charcoal toothpaste's biggest issue is its harshness. Over time, it can wear your enamel down. This might make your teeth look more yellow and hurt when you eat or drink.

It also can’t get rid of stains below the surface. It works best on the outside. That means it might not work for deeper stains or if the discoloration is from inside your teeth.

Charcoal toothpaste often skips fluoride, a key in preventing tooth decay. Fluoride makes teeth strong and guards them from harmful acids. That’s an important miss if you choose charcoal toothpaste.

In some cases, charcoal toothpaste’s particles can stick in older teeth's nooks and crannies. This might lead to more staining. Ensuring you brush well and rinse thoroughly is vital to avoid this issue.

Pros Cons
Can help remove surface stains Highly abrasive and can wear down tooth enamel
Improves bad breath Does not remove deep-set stains
Helps maintain results after a professional cleaning Most brands do not contain fluoride


Before adding charcoal toothpaste to your dental care, consider all sides. Think about what your oral health needs are. Talking to your dentist can help you make a wise choice for your teeth’s health and look.

Other Teeth Whitening Options

Looking beyond charcoal and purple toothpaste? You've got safe and effective teeth whitening alternatives. Consider whitening toothpastes. The ADA backs these for good reason. Aim for those with blue covarine and hydrogen peroxide. They're the best for whitening.

Among the choices are:

  • Whitening strips
  • In-office whitening treatments
  • Dentist-supervised at-home whitening

Want a natural touch for a whiter smile? Try hydrogen peroxide, baking soda, and apple cider vinegar at home.

But always, always speak with your dentist. They’ll help you find the right whitening path.

The Effectiveness of Whitening Strips and Paint-On Varnishes

Whitening strips and paint-on varnishes/gels are two easy ways to make teeth whiter. They are sold in many stores and do not need a dentist's visit. Even though they are not as strong as professional treatments, they still make teeth look better. Now, let's learn more about these choices.

Whitening Strips

Teeth whitening strips are better at making teeth whiter than special toothpaste. They have hydrogen peroxide, which is great for removing stains. The peroxide goes through the enamel and gets to the stains, removing them.

Using these strips correctly is crucial. Follow the instructions closely and use them regularly. More time means better results. But be careful not to leave them on too long, which could make your teeth or gums hurt.

Paint-On Varnishes and Gels

Paint-on varnishes and gels are also good for whitening teeth. You paint them onto your teeth with a small brush or pen. They work by breaking down stains and making teeth look whiter.

We know less about how well varnishes and gels work compared to other methods. The effects can be different for each person and product. Remember, they might not be as strong as treatments at the dentist.

Choosing between whitening strips and varnishes/ gels is up to you. Think about what you want and like. Talking to your dentist can help you pick the best way to whiten your teeth.


Choosing between charcoal toothpaste and purple toothpaste for teeth whitening is tough. Charcoal might remove surface stains, but it's rough and lacks fluoride. This raises worries about lasting use and tooth sensitivity. Purple toothpaste, with its color shift, makes teeth look whiter but doesn't actually whiten them. Both have their good and bad points.

There are also many other ways to whiten teeth. Besides whitening toothpastes that the ADA approves, you have blue covarine and hydrogen peroxide. These two are top whitening tech. It's also a good idea to look into whitening strips, treatments at the dentist's office, and at-home whitening with a dentist's help.

Natural methods like hydrogen peroxide, baking soda, and apple cider vinegar can also help. But, professional advice from a dentist is the best step. They can suggest what's right for you. Exploring all your options is key to getting the smile you want.


Is charcoal toothpaste safe to use?

Using charcoal toothpaste safely means using it properly. It's best not to use it every day because it can be rough on your teeth. There are worries it could wear down the hard outer layer of your teeth. This might lead to pain when eating something hot or cold. We're still learning about how safe and how well charcoal toothpaste works.

Does purple toothpaste work for whitening teeth?

Purple toothpaste tricks your eyes into thinking your teeth are whiter. How? It has an ingredient that shifts the color from yellow to blue. But, this effect is short-term and doesn't actually whiten your teeth. You'd need to keep using it to make your teeth seem whiter. We still need more research to know if it's truly safe and effective.

What are the benefits of charcoal toothpaste?

Charcoal toothpaste is good at removing some stains and freshening your breath. It might help keep your teeth from getting stained if you use it now and then after seeing your dentist. But, it doesn't have fluoride, a key ingredient for fighting tooth decay.

Are there any drawbacks to using charcoal toothpaste?

Charcoal toothpaste has its negatives too. It can scrub away the tough, outer layer of your teeth, which can make them look more yellow. It's not great at removing stains inside your teeth. Plus, using it every day might make your teeth hurt when you eat or drink something cold. Many types don't have fluoride, which can help prevent cavities. And, bits of charcoal can stick in grooves in older teeth, which might look like stains. We still don't know all the ways it might affect your teeth in the long run.

What are some other teeth whitening options?

Safe and good options for white teeth include ADA-approved whitening toothpastes. These can be found in stores. They often have special types of technology for whitening.

Whitening strips and treatments at the dentist both use hydrogen peroxide, which can work well. Over-the-counter products like gels can also offer some improvement. But, they're not as strong as what your dentist can use. For natural ways, some people find success with baking soda. But for the best choice, speak with your dentist.

How effective are whitening strips and paint-on varnishes for teeth whitening?

Whitening strips with hydrogen peroxide tend to work better than toothpaste. They can visibly change your teeth's color. Paint-on varnishes are okay, but we need more studies to know how well they work. Remember, what you get at the store might not be as strong as what a dentist could offer. Yet, they can still help make your teeth look better.

Which teeth whitening option is better: charcoal toothpaste or purple toothpaste?

Charcoal and purple toothpastes have their own advantages and disadvantages. Charcoal paste can take off some external stains. But, it can be too harsh and doesn't have fluoride.

Purple toothpaste can make your teeth seem whiter for a short time. Yet, it doesn't actually whiten them. The best choice depends on your needs. Talk to your dentist to find out the best options available.

Back to blog